Vital Football

Latest Hearts News

Should SPL Referees Now Be Professional?

Should SPL Referees Now Be Professional?

There are apparently genuine fears that the start of the SPL season could be delayed due to a dispute over money being paid to referees.

The SFA are meeting with the referees' committee today in an attempt to come to an agreement that will prevent the men in black going on strike this weekend, when the SPL season is due
to kick off. It's difficult to see a compromise not being reached when we consider just how much pain a delay to the season would cause so many different entities (the TV companies being the most obvious of those), but quite frankly I really hope that they don't, and that the whole issue of refereeing in this country goes right out there for examination.

In recent seasons referees seem to have come in for much more criticism than they ever did years ago. To be honest this is probably as much to do with the intense media coverage that today's game gets in comparison to yesteryear rather than the standard of refereeing being alarmingly worse than it was, although there is definitely an argument for the latter, something which admittedly hasn't been aided by some of the rule changes imposed by FIFA in recent years.

To many people, the very suggestion that the refs now want to be paid considerably more than they were per game (the figure being talked about is as much as £1,000 per game depending upon which stories you believe, an increase of at least 40%) when their performances have been questionable at best in recent times is almost laughable, but I don't necessarily see it that way. Kenny Clark, one of the more senior referees in the Scottish game, gave these comments to the BBC when asked about his argument for the increase:

'There are not any referees who will suggest they should get paid anything like what the players get.

'This is about giving some acknowledgment to the pressures they are under, and their families are under when it comes to media scrutiny.

'We are being asked to be professional, even though were amateur, in the way we conduct ourselves and we just want an increase in fees. In Greece, Norway and Holland they're getting paid more.'
While I don't think it matters how much their equivalents in other countries get paid as Clark cites here, he does make a fair point that referees have very responsible positions when it comes to the outcome of football matches. These guys regularly make decisions that can cost people millions of pounds, and the repercussions for getting things wrong could potentially be grave is certain people got their way. So I don't have a problem with people under such pressure wanting to be suitably compensated financially for this burden.

What I DO have a problem with though, is the fact that they'll probably end up getting this extra money but continue to be relatively unaccountable for mistakes that they make. Surely now if the SFA are going to start paying these guys what they think they're worth, which over the period of a season will net many of them pretty close to a decent annual salary in its own right on top of their 'day' jobs, then the whole issue of making referees into professionals in this country has to be looked at? This way, there could surely be no excuses when it came to unacceptable performances like the one that Mike McCurry turned in at Ibrox towards the end of last season - if they were professional then they would have to admit their mistakes and be punished accordingly for it. Simple. No?

Well.....no. The big problem that we have here is who the referees report to isn't it? Their bosses are shrouded in more controversy than the men in black themselves, so why should we stop at simply overhauling the whole strategy on refereeing in this country? Let's re-structure the SFA as well while we're at it! Or, at the very least open them up to some sort of positive change, one that would allow others to understand exactly why they came to certain decisions or recommendations.

Not that I expect this to happen of course.......it's more likely that anyone campaigning for this to happen will be fined for daring to 'question the integrity' of their closed shop operation, without realising once again that their continued silence on anything remotely controversial makes them appear even more corrupt that many already think that they are.

It certainly will be interesting to see what happens if no agreement can be reached at Hampden today though. At the very least some good will surely come out of it - for a start it will give Hearts a wee bit more time to try and get a few signings in to boost their chances of beating Motherwell!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:MrH
Date:Tuesday August 5 2008
Time: 1:20PM

Comments

0
Heard Graham Poll (yes, that world class referee who handed out three yellow cards to the same player in one game) on the radio this lunchtime, and he basically said that the increase was needed because if they get a big decision wrong, they could be banned for three matches - thus losing a lot of money. His argument is that if you get paid more, you're less likely to make a mistake because you have more to lose. I think that's all rear-about-face. Surely if they get paid more, they'll be able to stand the loss a lot more and continue to be as pathetically useless as they are now. Unless they are trying to argue that their living expenses have gone up by 80% in the last year? It's not as though it's even their day job. They should get a cost-of-expenses increase (say.. ohh.. I dunno... £25 extra per game or something) and be done with it. Oh, and be answerable to the clubs who are, after all, paying their wages.
StockportJambo
05/08/2008 13:36:00
0
£1000 a game?? Is this for big games or just every game? Surely they can't be asking for that sum for referring Hamilton Vs. St.Mirren. £500 a match is more than sufficient. As you say Mr.H, they don't take any responsibility when they make a horrendous decision. McCurry is a prime example of that. Is it true that they are even closing down their whistleblower website, the only available source which give an insight to their pish decisions think it’s a disgrace, as if these referees hadn’t disgraced themselves enough! Pathetic!
R.K
05/08/2008 13:41:00
0
SPL games only I think. From what I'm heard there's now every chance that Saturday's games will be cancelled.
MrH
05/08/2008 16:13:00
0
I've only heard bits and pieces about this but it seems that we may have a truly interesting prospect of change here. I think that Mr. H's suggestion that an increase in fees be linked to a more visible accountability would be a welcome move. However in a league that is struggling for funds having to plough the amounts of money being talked about at the top end of the speculation into referee wage increases seems unnecessary.
York Jambo
05/08/2008 17:21:00
0
I think if the refs do hold up the start of the league they will face an even greater wrath from the fans. As if they needed another excuse to abuse the refs.
R.K
05/08/2008 17:37:00
0
That's definitely true RK. In fact even the fact that they've now asked for more money will make them more of a target, as they'll be earning more money from a part-time job than many of the guys in the stands do in total.
MrH
05/08/2008 18:14:00
0
should rangers football club now be semi - professional ???????
wishaw bhoy
05/08/2008 20:40:00
0
Apparently they've reached a compromise of £800 per game. Pity - I agree that the relationship with the SFA would have come under scrutiny if the refs had gone on strike. After the Kanuas result, Rangers desperately need fully functioning refs to get their season back on track.
Specs Haver
05/08/2008 21:54:00
0
Well, they outdid themselves last season in their attempts to win them the championship, so expect them to be even worse this year!
MrH
05/08/2008 22:08:00
0
true, but at least after the mcurry incident people will be wiser to it, and at least one person will be sad enough to make a dossier of unadmitted mistakes and throw it in the SFA's face
hoopymo
06/08/2008 05:00:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Heart of Midlothian Articles

BBC Report - Prices Rise For 2017

The BBC's Price of Football annual survey was released this week, and their investigation shows that the price of football in Scotland has risen in three of the four divisions in 2017.

Berra Gets Scotland Call (7/11/17)

Hearts' Christophe Berra has been called up by Scotland interim manager Malky Mackay for the coming international break.

Hearts Duo Get Northern Ireland Call (7/11/17)

Hearts duo Aaron Hughes and Kyle Lafferty have been called up by Northern Ireland manager Michael O'Neill for the coming international break.

Hearts Duo Get Northern Ireland Call (26/9/17)

Hearts' Aaron Hughes and Kyle Lafferty have been called up by Northern Ireland manager Michael O'Neill for the coming international break.

Heart of Midlothian Archived Articles

Vital Hearts articles from

Site Journalists

Write for Vital Hearts
Write For Vital Hearts
Apply Here

Current Poll (see more polls)

Partick MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Hamilton4%
Paterson29%
Souttar6%
Rossi12%
Rherras3%
Sutchuin-Djoum3%
Cowie3%
Kitchen16%
Nicholson3%
Watt9%
Sammon3%
Sub - Johnsen3%
Sub - Walker3%
Sub - Smith3%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Heart of Midlothian Results (view all)

Heart of Midlothian Fixtures (view all)

Write for Vital Football