Vital Football

Latest Hearts News

What a difference 4 years makes for Hearts

What a difference 4 years makes for Hearts
Over on the Vital Celtic site, there is an article which seeks to show the drop in player quality by comparing today`s team with the one which made history in 2003 by reaching the UEFA Cup Final (and almost winning it).

In our case, we need only go back less than 4 years to demonstrate how Hearts have declined. Under George Burley (and subsequently Graham Rix and Valdas Ivanauskas), our team contained real quality players like Craig Gordon, Takis Fyssas, Steven Pressley, Andy Webster, Paul Hartley, Rudi Skacel, Roman Bednar. If events had not been scuppered by Romanov, all these guys would have commanded transfer fees well above 1m in 2006, and some of them would even have been beyond the buying power of the Old Firm. More importantly, their worth to Hearts in terms of performance within the team was huge.

Looking at the team today, we see a shadow of what Hearts were then. It is incredible to think that Hearts assembled such a talented squad only a few short years ago. Now, our only stars are a handful of youngsters around the age of 21 - Driver, Wallace and Craig Thomson. The crucial age group (late twenties) is empty. The mid-twenties age group has some potentially decent players - Kingston, Goncalves, Nade, Zaliukas - but each of them has "baggage" of some kind, which means their worth to the team is significantly less than we`d hope for.

As for the others that make up our current squad - Obua, Bouzid, Palazuelos, Santana, Balogh, Kello, Stewart, Black - well, they are simply not in the "2006 class", are they ? Maybe we can measure Hearts decline by simply looking at Robbie Neilson - who went from being possibly the weakest performer in 2006 to the best in 2009, without doing anything different !!

With the January transfer window looming and the artificially inflated demand from England likely to be the only activity in a declining transfer market, there is surely a strong chance that Romanov will want to cash in on his few remaining assets. Our lacklustre squad could lose Driver or Wallace in a few weeks time - leaving an even more depressing spectacle for the fans.

The euphoria we experienced only 4 years ago watching a high-scoring squad of players tear most teams apart now seems a lifetime away.

Writer:Specs Haver
Date:Tuesday November 3 2009
Time: 12:10AM

Best of Vital Scottish Football

Login to post a comment

Recent Heart of Midlothian Articles

Alexander Talks Hearts Exit - FC Infonet Change

Alexander has said there's 'no loyalty in football' (which I think we know anyway) after he was released by Hearts at the end of his deal with the veteran snapped up by Aberdeen.

FC Infonet In First Qualifying Round

Hearts have today been drawn with Estonian side FC Infonet in the first qualifying round draw of the 2016/17 Europa Cup competition.

Robbie Ready For Europe

Hearts will today find out who our first Europa League qualification opponents are with Neilson relishing this challenge.

Alexander To Aberdeen As Gallagher Arrives

Gallacher has had a move to Hearts confirmed with us also knowing this will see him take up a player-coach role. He rejected a new deal with Partick to pen a two-year deal.

Archived Vital Hearts Articles

Vital Hearts articles from

Site Journalists

Write for Vital Hearts
Write For Vital Hearts
Apply Here

Current Poll (see more polls)

St Johnstone MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Hamilton5%
Paterson0%
Souttar3%
Ozturk0%
Oshaniwa0%
Sutchuin-Djoum15%
Kitchen68%
Buaben3%
Moore3%
Delgado Lloria0%
Dauda3%
Sub - Smith0%
Sub - Nicholson0%
Sub - Reilly0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Celtic 38 26 8 4 86 62
2 Aberdeen 38 22 5 11 71 14
3 Hearts 38 18 11 9 65 19
4 St. Johnstone 38 16 8 14 56 3
5 Motherwell 38 15 5 18 50 -16
6 Ross County 38 14 6 18 48 -6
7 Inverness 38 14 10 14 52 6
8 Dundee 38 11 15 12 48 -4
9 Partick 38 12 10 16 46 -9
10 Hamilton 38 11 10 17 43 -21
11 Kilmarnock 38 9 9 20 36 -23
12 Dundee United 38 8 7 23 28 -25
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News

Recent Heart of Midlothian Results (view all)

Heart of Midlothian Fixtures (view all)