Vital Football

Latest Hearts News

Hearts lead SPL sceptics ?

Hearts lead SPL sceptics ?

Despite our much-maligned referees being apparently now happy with the world, the Scottish football circus continues to make a fool of itself with the SPL being the latest organisation to hit the headlines by trying to tell clubs to ignore their fans and chase the money.

Chief Executive Neil Doncaster has given several interviews where he tells us that even he`d like to see an INCREASED league, but it just wouldn`t work - so he wants 2 sets of 10 instead !!

Former Chief Executive Gordon Smith has also given several interviews where he tells us …. emm… nothing, really…. just his usual bland waffle. Why the BBC has given so much air-time (and fees) to this guy for over 10 years is baffling. Fair enough - he can talk reasonably coherently (unusual for an ex-player) … but he seldom says anything which the listener couldn`t deduce for himself.

Basically, it seems that the SPL have talked to broadcasters and sponsors and - surprise, surprise - they`ve replied that they`d want to see Celtic play Rangers every week !! So, Doncaster and his steering group of 6 clubs are recommending a 10-team SPL, with another 10 competing in an SPL 2 for some sort of play-off against the bottom clubs from the top league. There may even be play-offs for UEFA places. At long last though, an end to the artificial "split".

But wait a minute. Are play-offs really any different to the split ? Not in my opinion. Both are artificial milestones on the way to the final league positions - simply there to try to whet the appetites of some fans who think their team has achieved something…. prior to finding out that they haven`t.

Some of the recent survey findings were close to my own opinions -
Too many games (38 plus Cup)
Prices too high
Too much football on TV
Too much hassle for non-season ticket holders to attend a "spur of the moment" game
And last ..but NOT least - SQUADS and WAGES are TOO BIG

This last point is the one which Doncaster has failed to mention. How could Motherwell achieve 3rd place in 2008 on very modest wages and an average home crowd of 5,500 ? Hearts look like achieving 3rd this season on about 70% of the 2009 wage bill under Csaba (and playing much better football too) - any chance that Mr Doncaster could see a pattern emerging here, I wonder ?

Actually, I doubt it. It looks like he`s there simply to grab as much money in sponsorship and media deals as he can - job done !! Everyone agrees that most clubs are irresponsible when it comes to buying and paying players. So if it`s not feasible to impose a wage ceiling in football, how about reducing everyone's "artificial" income and forcing the clubs to see sense ? A 16-team league would give 30 games, plenty variety, home and away once against teach team, no split, less chance of a fixture log-jam after bad weather. Simply a return to what most fans want - a traditional league which encourages managers to play some home-produced youngsters each season.

Would Celtic and Rangers still win the league if they had to curtail their spending on players ? Yes, probably - but the competition from other clubs would surely be more realistic than it is now.

A study of the attendance figures of the main SPL clubs over the last 5 complete seasons (2005/06 to 2009/10) shows how each is likely to view the new SPL proposals.


. . . . . . Ground . . . . 5 Year . . . . 5 Year
. . . . . . Capacity . . . . Average . . . . Drop

Celtic . . . . . 60,000 . . . . . 55,200 . . . . . 21%
Rangers . . . . 51,000 . . . . . 48,900 . . . . . 3%
Hearts . . . . 17,500 . . . . . 15,700 . . . . . 13%
Hibs . . . . . . 20,000 . . . . . 13,300 . . . . . 13%
Aberdeen . . . 21,000 . . . . . 12,100 . . . . . 18%
Dundee U . . . 14,000 . . . . . 8,000 . . . . . 4%
Kilmar'k . . . . 18,000 . . . . . 6,500 . . . . . 16%
M'well . . . . . 13,500 . . . . . 5,900 . . . . . 15%


Celtic - a huge percentage drop in attendances, due probably to the Mowbray disaster more than anything. Quite simply their fans attend (or stay away) in direct proportion to the performance of their team - regardless of the opposition. No danger of relegation from a 10-team league, huge home support and not reliant on visiting fans for income. Likely to support 10-team SPL so long as they can win a big slice of the commercial benefits.

Rangers - fairly steady attendances, close to capacity. No danger of relegation from a 10-team league, huge home support and not reliant on visiting fans for income. Likely to support 10-team SPL so long as they can win a big slice of the commercial benefits.

Hearts - the 13% drop looks worse than it really is, due to the large attendances in the Cup-winning season (and the following one). Since then, just a small drop. Limited income derived from visiting fans - a match against anyone can pull in as many fans as a visit from the OF. Since they need to reduce the wage/squad, surely they`d be happy with fewer games. Likely to want a bigger league, I think

Hibs - although their finances are in good shape, they`ve just increased their capacity to 20,000 and will be looking for ways of filling the empty seats - so they`re likely to want 2 home games against Hearts and the OF in a 10-team league. That assuming that - ahem - they`re in it !!!

Aberdeen - having gone through a few managers and players in the last 2 years against a backdrop of falling crowds, it`s likely that they`ll see the 10-team league as the best way to reverse that trend - although they`ll be praying that Pa` Broon gets them out of the relegation area quick !!

Dundee Utd - chairman Stephen Thompson is on record as saying that they cannot continue paying wages at the current level, and their crowds are now below the 8,000 mark. The risk associated with that is getting involved in a relegation fight in a tight 10-team league. It`s little wonder he is against the proposal.

Kilmarnock - their crowds have dropped 16% since the days of Boyd and Naismith, although the team is going very well this season. Attendances from OF visits never come anywhere near capacity, and the relegation risk of being in a tight 10-team league will worry them.

Motherwell - despite their achievements under McGhee and Pa` Broon, their average attendance is consistently low. I`d be surprised if a 10-team league is to their advantage - maybe the lure of better commercial income is blinding John Boyle ?

Itinerant SPL clubs like Hamilton, St Mirren and St.Johnstone have very small fan bases and probably can be grouped alongside Motherwell in that respect. A drop to the lower SPL league may not hold too much of a financial penalty for them, especially if the proposal gives them some stability.

Interestingly, Inverness are reported as being against the proposal. Perhaps they have a greater ambition to remain in the top flight, with them having the Moray/Dornoch/Cromarty Firth areas to try to develop a bigger fan base.

What do you think of the 2-tier 10-team league proposals from the SPL ?

Writer:Specs Haver
Date:Wednesday January 5 2011
Time: 10:10PM

Best of Vital Scottish Football

Dundee United - Dundee United 1 Hibernian 0

Comments

0
like every other fan this debate is really starting to rile me!! especially the 'Dundee U / Aberdeen won the league in the 10 team format' - utter crap. the size of the league has no impact on the ultimate winners - they just have more cash to spend and more fan pull - hence their TV incomes. Personally I'd much rather a big league and play Queen of the South, Morton, Raith, Dundee, Partick... in exchange for a couple of our games against Hamilton, Motherwell etc - but the finances wont support that they say (though they will support 20 teams in 2 leagues?). could we do something different to keep 4 OF games a year, 4 derbies across the land? these are the games meaning the finances can't work, couldnt the league cup be reworked to support this, perhaps a mini league for the to 6 of the last year, while the rest join the ALBA cup?
ptown_jambo
08/01/2011 13:17:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Heart of Midlothian Articles

How Do Hearts Fare In The BBC's 2016 Survey?

The BBC's Price Of Football survey for 2016 was released a week last Wednesday evening and as ever they looked at everything from the price of tickets through to the price of pies...

Highest Ever Home Attendance Update (17/11/16)

This summer saw work undertaken to increase the capacity of Liverpool's home Anfield and Manchester City plan further work...

BBC Report - Scottish Prices Drop For 2016

The BBC's Price of Football annual survey was released late last night, and their investigation shows that the price of Scottish season tickets has fallen for 2016/17.

Vital Report - Hearts 2-0 Hamilton

Hearts' Scottish Premiership season continued with a win at Tynecastle against Hamilton on Saturday.

With Hearts winning once again, with the unbeaten run extended, the gap between them and Ch

Archived Vital Hearts Articles

Vital Hearts articles from

Site Journalists

Write for Vital Hearts
Write For Vital Hearts
Apply Here

Current Poll (see more polls)

Partick MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Hamilton2%
Paterson50%
Souttar0%
Rossi12%
Rherras0%
Sutchuin-Djoum0%
Cowie12%
Kitchen12%
Nicholson0%
Watt0%
Sammon12%
Sub - Johnsen0%
Sub - Walker0%
Sub - Smith0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Celtic 13 12 1 0 37 28
2 Rangers 16 8 5 3 29 4
3 Aberdeen 15 8 3 4 27 13
4 Hearts 16 7 6 3 27 12
5 St. Johnstone 15 6 4 5 22 3
6 Kilmarnock 16 4 5 7 17 -14
7 Ross County 16 3 7 6 16 -11
8 Hamilton 15 2 9 4 15 -4
9 Motherwell 15 4 3 8 15 -7
10 Dundee 16 4 3 9 15 -8
11 Partick 15 3 5 7 14 -5
12 Inverness 16 3 5 8 14 -11
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Heart of Midlothian Results (view all)

Heart of Midlothian Fixtures (view all)

Dec 10 2016 3:00PM : Rangers (a)
Scottish Premiership
Dec 17 2016 3:00PM : Partick Thistle (H)
Scottish Premiership
Dec 23 2016 7:45PM : Dundee (a)
Scottish Premiership
Dec 27 2016 7:45PM : Kilmarnock (H)
Scottish Premiership
Dec 30 2016 7:45PM : Aberdeen (H)
Scottish Premiership
Jan 21 2017 3:00PM : Raith Rovers (a)
Scottish FA Cup
The Vital Football Members League